Sign in / Register
CONTACT US:(801) 537-7800

New Hire Success: Fixing Broken Onboarding

A few years ago, on the first day of a new job, my boss sent me downstairs to the IT guy, who was going to teach me a complicated software system. As he went over the basics of navigating the system, I watched intently, taking mental and written notes. Half an hour into the demonstration, my eyes got heavy, and the heaviness spread to my whole head. I was nodding off right in front of my new co-worker – big, pronounced nods.

Naturally, I was embarrassed. He didn’t say anything about it, didn’t change course, and continued to drone on about keyboard shortcuts, menus and … something about file extensions? My brain had checked out. I kept waiting to get my hands on the mouse and keyboard and try things out, but that didn’t happen. He continued the college lecture for another hour or two. He was a nice guy, but this onboarding was brutal.

The Problem with Old-School Onboarding

Your employees may feel similarly bored and unengaged during your onboarding process, and that’s a bigger deal than you may think. Remember that saying about first impressions? You get to make only one; and first impressions are lasting impressions. A poor first impression can leave your new hires looking for greener pastures.

Voluntary turnover is a big reason to fix your old, broken onboarding. In 2014, 22% of employees quit their jobs, marking the fourth consecutive year that the percentage had grown. Another figure that should give you pause: on average, 56% of job quitting happens within the first year. Here’s one more, on how expensive turnover is: The cost to replace and hire new staff can be anywhere from 90% to 200% of an annual salary.

So what’s going on here? Well, very often, onboarding revolves around procedural, compliance-based activities, as it did in my story. The result is an impersonal, unengaging, instruction- and document-heavy experience that lacks follow-up and reinforcement. All in all, new hires miss out on feeling a real connection with the company and their job, and without onboarding follow-up, certain knowledge and skills will fall by the wayside, requiring the employee to use up time relearning their duties.

The best companies use the onboarding process to:

  • Excite and inspire
  • Tell a story, establish context
  • Create a connection
  • Inform without overloading
  • Reinforce

Tips for More Engaging Onboarding

To accomplish those goals consider using the following strategies to make your onboarding more effective and engaging.

Incorporate video. Video has the power to create a connection and motivate, mainly because video tells a story, and stories are compelling. Often the story is about the company, its culture and where the new hire fits in.

Think about it: It’s hard to convey company culture in an instructor-led training with 250 new hires, or in a sitdown in a small room. Company culture is ethereal, hard to pin down in words. But a video can convey the culture via images, music, and a story, tapping the emotions of and resonating with the employees.

Culture and branding videos get new hires excited and motivated to work at your company. That positive first impression stays with them, improving retention. To that end, consider including in your video the experiences of current employees. They likely have some impactful stories to share. You can also consider crafting a narrative about a fictional consumer who is affected by the actions of the employee.

Another practical use of video is in skill demonstration. How-to videos are easy to understand, and they’re easily accessible, as opposed to, say, an expert at the company who may not always be available to answer questions. A quick 30-second video avoids overloading employees with too much new information.

Provide opportunities for hands-on work. Speaking of information overload, it’s important to break up your instruction with practice sessions, so the new hire gets some actual hands-on experience while the demonstration is still fresh in his mind. Recall in my onboarding story how I was champing at the bit to practice what the IT guy was showing me. Instead, I was getting dumped with how-to’s without a chance to get behind the wheel.

Human memory is limited, so examples and modeling are almost useless if there’s no immediate opportunity to practice. I felt like I was being shown how to tie 20 knots and expected to demonstrate them all at the end of training.

Follow up. We tend to think onboarding happens over the first week or two, and then it’s done. That’s closer to orientation than onboarding. Onboarding is an ongoing process that takes place over months, even up to a year. Frequent follow-up is critical if you want your new hire to retain knowledge and skills.

To that end, assign a mentor who can perform check-ins and review the new hire’s work. A mentor should be the go-to person for any questions the new hire has. Often, without a mentor, a new hire may feel hesitant to ask questions, as he feels he will simply be bugging the person he’s asking.

An effective, engaging onboarding process will get your employees comfortable, excited, and connected, setting them up for long-term success at your company. Start making your fixes today.

representative talent profile

instructional writer

Position(s): Lead or supporting writer
Years of Instructional Experience: 2+
Number of Completed Projects: 15+

Key Skills: Instructional Writing, Technical Writing, Instructional Design, Content Curation, eLearning Development, Curriculum Development, Course Authoring, Storytelling, Learning Assessment, Editing, Proofreading, AI Prompt Engineering

Media Skills: Use of stock media libraries

Strengths: Problem-Solving, Clear and Concise Writing, Tone and Style, Formatting, Consistency, Creativity, Communication, Active Listening, Research, Brainstorming, Collaboration, Attention to Detail, Adaptability

Career Highlights:

  • Scripted over 100 hours of learning content and supporting materials for different modalities for both US and global audiences  
  • Adapted writing style and reading grade level to suit design specifications and learner needs in several different industries (finance, healthcare, manufacturing, etc.) 
  • Used generative AI to supplement source content and to accelerate the writing process (without plagiarism) 

Technical Skills:

representative talent profile

learning experience designer

Position(s): Learning Experience (LX) Designer or Strategist
Years of Instructional Experience: 7+
Number of Completed Projects: 30+

Key Skills: Learner Experience Design (LXD),  Instructional Design, Learning Assessment,  Hybrid Learning, Learning in the Flow of Work, Project-Based Learning Methodologies, Cohort and Social Learning, Learner Experience Platforms

Media Skills: LX journey maps and representations of other interconnected or integrated learning strategies 

Strengths: Systems Thinking, Stakeholder Communication, Instructional Design Strategy, Learning Theory, Training Effectiveness

Career Highlights:

  • Designed personalized learner experience (LX) journeys for an organization of 30k (with 5 tiered tracks) 
  • Curated existing LXs that could be leveraged in new learning journeys for other roles, with measurement at key milestones to evaluate progress and success 
  • Wrote up the specifications for branching scenarios, question libraries, options for audio/visual media, and more, connecting each learner experience to a personalized journey 

Technical Skills:

representative talent profile

instructional media specialist

Position(s): Lead or supporting graphic designer, lead motion video artist
Years of Instructional Experience: 6+
Number of Completed Projects: 40+

Key Skills: Visual Design, Illustration, UX/UI Design, Storyboarding, Animation, Audio Engineering

Media Skills: Engaging illustrations, 3D models, character design, storyboarding, live-action and motion graphic video creation, audio recording and editing, client branding, and more to enhance media and create engaging touchpoints that resonate with learners 

Strengths: Brainstorming, Collaboration, Visual Communication,  Color Theory, Typography, Layout and Composition

Career Highlights:

  • Completed projects with extreme attention to fonts, colors, spacing, and more that ensured integrity with client branding requirements 
  • Designed and integrated media based on project-specific content that reflected the learner audience, established realistic learning environments, allowed for hands-on practice in virtual environments, and promoted diversity and engaging storytelling
  • Created quick-reference illustrations learners could access on the job to help them make fast, effective decisions   

Technical Skills:

representative talent profile

lms admin

Position(s): Admin or sub-admin for Learning Management System (LMS)
Years of Instructional Experience: 5+
Number of Completed Projects: 15+

Key Skills: LMS Configuration, User Management, Course Management, System Maintenance, Reporting, Data Analysis, System Integrations

Media Skills: Network and tech-stack diagrams to communicate system architecture and integration 

Strengths: Troubleshooting and Analysis, Learning Analytics, User Administration, Technical Proficiency, Documentation, Adaptability

Career Highlights:

  • Managed a curriculum of more than 1,450 course offerings in the LMS for more than 10,000 learners 
  • Uploaded, tested, and ensured the readiness of new and relaunched programs 
  • Created and maintained reporting workflows to meet stakeholder needs 
  • Provided on-demand support to the learning team to answer questions and promptly address concerns 

Technical Skills:

representative talent profile

learning project manager

Position(s): Learning project manager, project lead, or coordinator
Years of Instructional Experience: 5+
Number of Completed Projects: 35+

Key Skills: eLearning Development, Resource Coordination, Project Management (PMP Certified), Agile and Waterfall PM Methodologies, Budgeting and Forecasting, Scheduling, Quality Assurance

Media Skills: Visual reporting of project plans via Gantt charts and other standard formats

Strengths: Problem-Solving, Communication, Active Listening, Collaboration, Decision-Making, Attention to Detail, Adaptability, Time Management, Risk Management, Budget Management, Team Coordination and Delegation

Career Highlights:

  • Managed concurrent award-winning projects without missing deadlines or wasting resources 
  • Completed several projects earlier than the expected timeline and under the anticipated budget 
  • Built strong relationships with returning client partners for multi-phase initiatives or course maintenance projects 

Technical Skills:

representative talent profile

SUBJECT MATTER EXPERT (SME)

Position(s): Industry-specific specialist
Years of Instructional Experience: 5+
Number of Completed Projects: 5+

Key Skills: Content Curation, Specialized Content Development, Industry-Specific Expertise, Domain Expertise (e.g., Leadership, Onboarding, Compliance), Content Review

Media Skills: Recommendation and review of technical diagrams or industry-specific images

Strengths: Specialized Content Knowledge, Content-Gathering, Simplifying and Organizing Complex Material, Brainstorming, Collaboration, Documentation of Source Content, Decision-Making, Technical Content Review

Career Highlights:

  • Helped create, gather, and organize over 50 hours of content for projects with specific industry or learning needs and contextual nuances
  • Facilitated the decision-making process and collaboration between internal and external teams to consolidate feedback into actionable next steps 

Technical Skills:

representative talent profile

LEARNING STRATEGIST

Position(s): Lead strategist or performance consultant
Years of Instructional Experience: 7+
Number of Completed Projects: 20+

Key Skills: Needs Analysis, Learning Theory, Learner Experience Design, Learning Analytics and Measurement, Performance Mapping, Behavioral and Performance Analysis, Content Curation, Curriculum Analysis, Change Management

Media Skills: Curriculum maps, learner experience journeys, and conceptual program wireframes

Strengths: Big-Picture Thinking, Critical Thinking and Analysis, Problem-Solving, Creativity, Stakeholder Communication, Research, Design, Collaboration, Facilitation

Career Highlights:

  • Conducted a comprehensive learning needs analysis for customer services representatives that included both product knowledge and interpersonal skills development 
  • Prioritized alignment of business and learner needs, such as high-impact accessible design solutions within budgets or agile timelines, for award-winning projects
  • Designed strategies for measuring performance and results over time to inform continued client success 

Technical Skills:

representative talent profile

Instructional Designers

Position(s): Lead or supporting designer
Years of Instructional Experience: 3+
Number of Completed Projects: 15+

Key Skills: Instructional Design, Adult Learning Theories, eLearning Development, Learner Experience Design, Curriculum Development, Course Authoring, Writing, Learning Assessment

Media Skills: Simple graphic design using stock imagery, audio production

Strengths: Adaptability, Problem-Solving, Creativity, Communication, Collaboration, Technical Proficiency, Attention to Detail

Career Highlights:

  • Led the design and development of an onboarding program for new manufacturing employees
  • Scripted technical instructional content for high-tech, product knowledge training
  • Developed hybrid materials for both instructor-led training (ILT) and microlearning tutorials

Technical Skills: